Why would you ever distrust a peer-reviewed journal? Isn’t peer review the gold standard for quality in academia? Aren’t we always being told to rely on peer reviewed scholarly literature instead of personal opinions and non-scholarly sources. This video shows you there can be good reasons to distrust peer-reviewed journals, and explains that peer-review doesn’t always mean what you might think it means.
Media credit
AA-VFX. “Talent Show ★ Shooting Stars ★ 4K Moving Backgrounds for Edits ║ Animated Video Effect ║ Production.” YouTube, 14 September 2021. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JlyJpDabyNg.
Sources
admin. “#PebbleGate.” The Cosmic Tusk, 1 October 2021. https://cosmictusk.com/pebblegate/.
Baethge, Christopher. “Publish Together or Perish: The Increasing Number of Authors per Article in Academic Journals Is the Consequence of a Changing Scientific Culture. Some Researchers Define Authorship Quite Loosely.” Deutsches Arzteblatt International 105.20 (2008): 380–83. https://doi.org/10.3238/arztebl.2008.0380.
biskrensis, Actinopolyspora. “PubPeer Comment on: Platinum, Shock-Fractured Quartz, Microspherules, and Meltglass Widely Distributed in Eastern USA at the Younger Dryas Onset (12.8 Ka)” (2024). https://pubpeer.com/publications/F5D96FDA02483CC7B17014305B292E#1.
———. “PubPeer Comment on: Platinum, Shock-Fractured Quartz, Microspherules, and Meltglass Widely Distributed in Eastern USA at the Younger Dryas Onset (12.8 Ka)” (2024). https://pubpeer.com/publications/F5D96FDA02483CC7B17014305B292E#5.
Bonacchi, Chiara, Marta Krzyzanska, and Alberto Acerbi. “Positive Sentiment and Expertise Predict the Diffusion of Archaeological Content on Social Media.” Sci Rep 15.1 (2025): 2031. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-025-85167-z.
Boslough, Mark. “Apocalypse! Why Graham Hancock’s Use of the Younger Dryas Impact Hypothesis in His Netflix Series Ancient Apocalypse Is All Wet.” Skeptic, 21 April 2023. https://www.skeptic.com/reading_room/graham-hancocks-ancient-apocalypse-hypothesis-put-to-test/.
———. “It’s Time to Retract the Sodom Airburst Paper.” Mark Boslough, 20 September 2022. https://www.boslough.us/blog/bunch.
———. “Sodom Meteor Strike Claims Should Be Taken with a Pillar of Salt.” Skeptical Inquirer 46.1 (2022). https://skepticalinquirer.org/2021/12/sodom-meteor-strike-claims-should-be-taken-with-a-pillar-of-salt/.
Bunch, Ted E., Malcolm A. LeCompte, A. Victor Adedeji, James H. Wittke, T. David Burleigh, Robert E. Hermes, Charles Mooney, Dale Batchelor, Wendy S. Wolbach, et al. “A Tunguska Sized Airburst Destroyed Tall El-Hammam a Middle Bronze Age City in the Jordan Valley near the Dead Sea.” Sci Rep 11.1 (2021): 18632. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-97778-3.
———. “PubPeer Comments on: A Tunguska Sized Airburst Destroyed Tall El-Hammam a Middle Bronze Age City in the Jordan Valley near the Dead Sea” (2021). https://pubpeer.com/publications/37B87CAC48DE4BC98AD40E00330143#4.
Caron, Minal M., Carolyn T. Lye, Barbara E. Bierer, and Mark Barnes. “The PubPeer Conundrum: Administrative Challenges in Research Misconduct Proceedings.” Accountability in Research 0.0 (n.d.): 1–19. https://doi.org/10.1080/08989621.2024.2390007.
Carter, Jamie. “A Comet Exploded Above North America 12,800 Years Ago, Say Scientists.” Forbes, 6 July 2024. https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamiecartereurope/2024/07/06/a-comet-exploded-above-north-america-12800-years-ago-say-scientists/.
DeDunking. “A Retraction, 2 Apologies and a Rant DeDunking Channel Update.” YouTube, 21 May 2023. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=akAI85j1HGw.
———. “Archaeologist John Hoopes Corrupts Wikipedia #archaeology #science #wikipedia.” YouTube, 12 July 2024. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0s-69GKqp-s.
———. “I Made a Mistake Let’s Learn From It Retraction of DNA Video.” YouTube, 12 August 2024. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mILWHI36mlw.
———. “I Was Wrong About Ben’s Ancient Egyptian Vases UnchartedX.” YouTube, 19 September 2024. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qEA1ZeNXYF8.
———. “Open Letter to Society for American Archaeology President #archaeology #psychology #alternatehistory.” YouTube, 8 July 2024. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O-xUZrAWzno.
dione, Hypanartia. “PubPeer Comment on: A Tunguska Sized Airburst Destroyed Tall El-Hammam a Middle Bronze Age City in the Jordan Valley near the Dead Sea” (2021). https://pubpeer.com/publications/37B87CAC48DE4BC98AD40E00330143#20.
Editorial, BOSS. “Evaluating and Comparing Scientific Journals: A Comprehensive Guide.” BOSS Magazine, 24 May 2023. https://thebossmagazine.com/evaluating-comparing-scientific-journals/.
Elmore, Susan A., and Eleanor H. Weston. “Predatory Journals: What They Are and How to Avoid Them.” Toxicol Pathol 48.4 (2020): 607–10. https://doi.org/10.1177/0192623320920209.
Flaherty, Colleen. “When Journals Play Favorites.” Inside Higher Ed, 1 March 2018. https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2018/03/02/study-finds-evidence-institutional-favoritism-academic-publishing.
george. “Comet Research Group Kicks off New Journal with Blockbuster Papers.” The Cosmic Tusk, 3 October 2023. https://cosmictusk.com/airbursts-and-cratering-impacts/.
George, Zach St. “The Comet Strike Theory That Just Won’t Die.” The New York Times, 5 March 2024, § Magazine. https://www.nytimes.com/2024/03/05/magazine/younger-dryas-impact-hypothesis-comet.html.
Holliday, Vance T., Tyrone L. Daulton, Patrick J. Bartlein, Mark B. Boslough, Ryan P. Breslawski, Abigail E. Fisher, Ian A. Jorgeson, Andrew C. Scott, Christian Koeberl, et al. “Comprehensive Refutation of the Younger Dryas Impact Hypothesis (YDIH).” Earth-Science Reviews 247 (2023): 104502. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.earscirev.2023.104502.
Jaret, Steven J., and R. Scott Harris. “No Mineralogic or Geochemical Evidence of Impact at Tall El-Hammam, a Middle Bronze Age City in the Jordan Valley near the Dead Sea.” Sci Rep 12.1 (2022): 5189. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-022-08216-x.
Kim, Shi En. “Academic Journals Move Toward Open Access.” APS, 16 February 2024. https://www.aps.org/apsnews/2024/02/journals-open-access-reduce-inequity.
Kincaid, Ellie. “Journal Investigating Sodom Comet Paper for Data Problems.” Retraction Watch, 21 February 2023. https://retractionwatch.com/2023/02/21/journal-investigating-sodom-comet-paper-for-data-problems/.
Marcus, Adam. “Criticism Engulfs Paper Claiming an Asteroid Destroyed Biblical Sodom and Gomorrah.” Retraction Watch, 1 October 2021. https://retractionwatch.com/2021/10/01/criticism-engulfs-paper-claiming-an-asteroid-destroyed-biblical-sodom-and-gomorrah/.
Moore, Christopher R., Malcolm A. LeCompte, James P. Kennett, Mark J. Brooks, Richard B. Firestone, Andrew H. Ivester, Terry A. Ferguson, Chad S. Lane, Kimberly A. Duernberger, et al. “Platinum, Shock-Fractured Quartz, Microspherules, and Meltglass Widely Distributed in Eastern USA at the Younger Dryas Onset (12.8 Ka).” Airbursts and Cratering Impacts 2 (2024): 20240003. https://doi.org/10.14293/ACI.2024.0003.
———. “PubPeer Comments on: Platinum, Shock-Fractured Quartz, Microspherules, and Meltglass Widely Distributed in Eastern USA at the Younger Dryas Onset (12.8 Ka)” (2024). https://pubpeer.com/publications/F5D96FDA02483CC7B17014305B292E.
Ortega, José Luis. “Classification and Analysis of PubPeer Comments: How a Web Journal Club Is Used.” Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology 73.5 (2022): 655–70. https://doi.org/10.1002/asi.24568.
Powell, James Lawrence. “Peer Review and the Pillar of Salt: A Case Study.” Research Ethics 19.1 (2023): 78–89. https://doi.org/10.1177/17470161221131491.
Rasmussen, Martin. “Termination of the Journal Pattern Recognition in Physics.” Pattern Recognition in Physics, January 2014. https://www.pattern-recognition-in-physics.net/.
Scanff, Alexandre, Florian Naudet, Ioana A. Cristea, David Moher, Dorothy V. M. Bishop, and Clara Locher. “A Survey of Biomedical Journals to Detect Editorial Bias and Nepotistic Behavior.” PLOS Biology 19.11 (2021): e3001133. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.3001133.
Silvia, Phillip J., Steven Collins, Malcolm A. LeCompte, Luis Duarte Costa, George A. Howard, James P. Kennett, Christopher R. Moore, Gunther Kletetschka, A. Victor Adedeji, et al. “Modeling How a Powerful Airburst Destroyed Tall El-Hammam, a Middle Bronze Age City near the Dead Sea.” Airbursts and Cratering Impacts 2 (2024): 20240005. https://doi.org/10.14293/ACI.2024.0005.
Singh Chawla, Dalmeet. “How Reliable Is This Research? Tool Flags Papers Discussed on PubPeer.” Nature 629.8011 (2024): 271–72. https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-024-01247-6.
Sumpter, John P., Tamsin J. Runnalls, Andrew C. Johnson, and Damia Barcelo. “A ‘Limitations’ Section Should Be Mandatory in All Scientific Papers.” Science of The Total Environment 857 (2023): 159395. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2022.159395.
Sweatman, Martin B., James L. Powell, and Allen West. “Rejection of Holliday et al.’s Alleged Refutation of the Younger Dryas Impact Hypothesis.” Earth-Science Reviews 258 (2024): 104960. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.earscirev.2024.104960.
Venema, Victor. “Peer Review Helps Fringe Ideas Gain Credibility.” Peer Review Helps Fringe Ideas Gain Credibility, 27 January 2014. https://variable-variability.blogspot.com/2014/01/peer-review-helps-fringe-ideas-gain.html.
West, Allen. “PubPeer Comment on: Platinum, Shock-Fractured Quartz, Microspherules, and Meltglass Widely Distributed in Eastern USA at the Younger Dryas Onset (12.8 Ka)” (2024). https://pubpeer.com/publications/F5D96FDA02483CC7B17014305B292E#2.
“Airbursts and Cratering Impacts.” ScienceOpen, n.d. https://www.scienceopen.com/collection/9aae92f3-66ba-4b71-a74b-51b9995c56e5.
“Airbursts and Cratering Impacts.” Exaly, n.d. https://exaly.com/journal/170507/airbursts-and-cratering-impacts.
“Airbursts and Cratering Impacts.” Exaly, n.d. https://exaly.com/journal/170507/airbursts-and-cratering-impacts.
“Bear & Company – Imprints,” n.d. https://www.innertraditions.com/imprints/bear-company.
“Jamie Carter.” Jamie Carter, n.d. https://jamieacarter.com/.
“PubPeer – Search Publications and Join the Conversation.,” n.d. https://pubpeer.com/static/about.
“Retraction Watch Database.” Retraction Database, January 2008. https://retractiondatabase.org/RetractionSearch.aspx#?ttl%3dModeling%2bhow%2ba%2bPowerful%2bAirburst%2bdestroyed%2bTall%2bel-Hammam%252c%2ba%2bMiddle%2bBronze%2bAge%2bcity%2bnear%2bthe%2bDead%2bSea.
“Richard Firestone – View Obituary & Service Information.” Richard Firestone Obituary, n.d. https://oakland.chapelofthechimes.com/obituaries/Richard-Firestone-3/.
“The Center For Scientific Integrity.” Retraction Watch, 27 March 2015. https://retractionwatch.com/the-center-for-scientific-integrity/.
“Web of Science Master Journal List – WoS MJL by Clarivate,” n.d. https://mjl.clarivate.com/home.
